Wednesday, September 25, 2013

The 3% Rule – Part Two


As a follow up to the article about the 3% rule
(http://divorce-mortgage.blogspot.com/2013/07/the-we-didnt-think-this-one-through-rule.html), we have received a clarification. The CFPB has recently announced that Loan Officer Compensation (LO Comp) will not count against the 3% limitation for bankers but it will count against the limit for brokers. This is the proverbial “nail in the coffin” for the broker industry. No one is expected to attend the funeral. Since we do not have parallel universes, consumers will not miss the broker because there will be no measuring stick. Two bits of information might be helpful (in understanding our current plight) while it does nothing to truly help any consumer. First of all, according to the preeminent researcher for the banking and broker industry – Tom LaMalfa – independent mortgage brokers provided lower rates and fees for consumers than their mammoth competition, the big banks. Secondly, according to J. D. Power & Associates, consumers were more satisfied with brokers than they were with the big banks. One reason was because brokers provided alternatives and choices. They were, in effect, one-stop shops. You could stick with a good broker for life. Well, for life until Chris Dudd and Barney Freak killed ‘em. To be honest, brokers were under attack from George Bush’s HUD Secretary, Mel Martinez who, interestingly enough, had been head of the Texas Savings and Mortgage Lending Department under W.

Nevertheless, brokers will no longer exist after January 1st, 2014. Oh yes, to be considerate of time lines, the CFPB moved the date of the announced changes from January 14th to January 1st because changing the books in the middle of the month would be unhelpful. So glad they’re watching out for us.


Oh! You want to know why brokers cannot exist under the new 3% rule, eh? I suppose I should explain. With a 3% cap on closing costs, lower loan amounts will be subject to higher rates and, many times, loan denials because there simply is not enough room in the 3% cap to include all of the costs of doing a loan; and the rate will have to be raised in order to recoup costs through the higher yields that higher rates bring in the secondary market.  For brokers, their compensation – anywhere from .750 to 2.00% generally – the 3% cap becomes a 1% - 2.250% cap because we have the broker has to subtract his/her compensation from the 3% and make all costs fit under that amount. This is simply impossible for loan amounts lower than about $350,000. In theory, brokers who service high dollar markets – loan amounts of not less than $300,000 or so – can still operate. The problem is that so few of them will be able to operate that the lenders/banks who received loans from them will no longer keep a broker line (called “wholesale”) open for the few remaining brokers. In fact, major banks like Wells Fargo and Bank of America shut down their broker lines a few years ago.


Why whine and complain and moan about the loss of the broker industry? Politically, it’s important because it demonstrates that our government cares less about what is truly good for the consumer and more about the lobbyists (like the big banks) who wrote the rules and monopolized the lending industry. Practically, it’s important because fewer people can obtain mortgages and fewer still will be able to shop for good service. Very soon, the borrowing public will have a choice between about 3-5 major banks. You know, those banks that cannot be allowed to get “too big to fail.” Personally, I have minimized the impact upon me because for almost 4 years now, I have been a “banker” and needed “broker” outlets only occasionally. So, the rule affects me and my colleagues only minimally. (A few of our loans are brokered because we have broker agreements as opposed to “correspondent” agreements with certain lenders who, from time to time, are able to do loans that our “correspondent” lenders cannot or will not do). The consumer will be more hurt than we will be.


Within our industry, here’s the buzz...I mean, the spin. “Let’s quit complaining about the regulatory changes, the loss of income or the increased work load because of compliance. The good news is that masses of people have exited the industry which leaves only the strong standing. If you’ve made it this far, guess what – consumers out there don’t have as many options. Your competition has vanished!”


What a perverted way to make a living.  


Personally, I’ve never been bothered by competition. It’s never occurred to me that I should be in the enviable position of the monopolist. Competition is good for the consumer and ultimately good for the industry. Competition encourages excellence, efficiency and lower costs. But, I’m naïve. And my government is astute to its own devices and designs. So, the consumer suffers without knowing that the difficulties need not be so difficult.


Repeal Dodd-Frank. Return this country to constitutional government. Eradicate monopolies and uneven regulations which are designed to enrich political allies and impoverish political “nobodies.”

Wednesday, July 24, 2013

The "We Didn't Think This One Through" Rule


New rules from the *CFPB will dramatically affect the ability of all borrowers to obtain mortgages. This post will analyze and expose the devastating effects of a second rule – the 3% rule.


The “We-Didn’t-Think-This-One-Through-Just-Ask-Texas-Mortgage-Originators” 3% Rule

The bureau’s general guideline reads

No excess upfront points and fees: A Qualified Mortgage limits points and fees including those used to compensate loan originators, such as loan officers and brokers. When lenders tack on excessive points and fees to the origination costs, consumers end up paying a lot more than planned.

The last post began with “Richard Cordray of the CFPB declares ‘All American borrowers are stupid and we have to save them.’" Of course, he didn’t say it exactly that way but the proposed rules effectively say it. [That's him on the right. Don't be fooled - I'm sure no head of a bureau created by Dodd-Frank could possibly be a political activist. Ignore the Barack Obama poster in front of him.]


One of those rules that will allegedly protect consumers is the 3% Rule.

The 3% Rule is a cap on closing costs. It requires that closing costs cannot exceed 3% of the loan amount. (There is some variance for loan amount less than $100,000). Also, the bureau has only vaguely specified what fees might be exempt from this accounting. It has, however, signaled that the loan officer compensation will be counted against this fee cap. While a CFPB bulletin in January 2013 stated that

The Bureau has decided not to finalize the proposal [something about LO compensation] at this time, however, because of concerns that it would have created consumer confusion and other negative outcomes. The Bureau has decided instead to issue a complete exemption to the prohibition on upfront points and fees pursuant to its exemption authority under section 1403 while it scrutinizes several crucial issues relating to the proposal’s design, operation, and possible effects in a mortgage market undergoing regulatory overhaul.

A **bulletin released in April of this year indicates the full implementation to include Loan Officer Compensation in the 3% limitation on closing costs.
 
To those outside the industry, this may appear confusing at worst and falsely helpful at best. Let me give you 5 facts that will help clarify:


1.    Costs are not the same as prices. The many costs that comprise “closing costs” are insensitive to government regulations. Appraisers, for example, do not lower their fees because some agency requires that the total fees not exceed a certain amount. Neither do the gas stations (from which they purchase the fuel to power their vehicles) lower the price of their product as the appraisers travel to the properties to perform their inspections. While prices are capped by government, costs cannot be so easily controlled.

2. Loan Officer Compensation is not the same as the origination fee, the processing fee or other fees listed as going to the lender.

3. Loan Officers are most frequently paid not only from any “origination fee” but from the yield paid by the investor-lender which funds the loan. Think about those things that are almost a thing-of-the-past, the “no closing cost” loan. With no closing costs, including no origination fee, how do you think anyone was paid. They were paid by the investor who purchased the loan which was made at a higher than “par rate” which paid a specific percentage of the loan amount.

4. These yields can go as high as 7%-8% but are often “eaten up” in other costs. (More on that later; but, they are called LLPA’s Loan Level Pricing Adjustments . . . another way for Fannie and Freddie to collect fees).

5. Loan officers typically make .7% - 2% as a commission on their loans per their contract with their employing lender. Many economic factors affect this commission structure, not the least of which is the market in which the loan officer works. That is, the loan officer who serves a market of mostly $80,000 mortgages and makes 2% on her loans will work just as hard and diligently as the loan officer who serves a market of mostly $400,000 mortgages making only .7% on his loans, yet she will net less real dollar for the same number of loans closed as her counterpart in the higher dollar market.

 
The CFPB’s proposed rules – specifically the 3% Rule - regarding the “ability to repay” are unnecessary and harmful to the economy and the lending industry but mostly to consumers. Here’s why, point by point.

Price controls never work to the benefit of consumers. The proposed 3% limit on closing costs cannot fare any better than any other price controls. And because the proposal also includes restrictions upon the wages of the mortgage professionals, it’s quite possibly unconstitutional, not to mention insane. But whether it’s insane, illegal or just pure nonsense, one thing is inescapable – it’s still harmful to the consumer. Wage and price controls have never inured to the benefit of the consumers. They always – without exception – produce shortages (a lack of available credit) and diminished quality (a lack of service and ultimately a lack of access to credit). In the case of mortgages, the shortage is simply running out of dollars (allowed by law) available to pay the fixed costs.

A fixed percentage unfairly discriminates against borrowers with lower loan amounts. By placing limits on closing costs AS A PERCENTAGE OF A LOAN AMOUNT, the CFPB effectively denies the “do-ability” of loan amounts below certain thresholds. This should be obvious. But, obvious it is not. So, let me illustrate. Nearly all closing “costs” are fixed. If they are not fixed they are certainly not subject to percentages. For example, the costs to have attorneys draw up the loan documents is about $350. Doc prep attorneys charge this amount whether the loan amount is $100,000 or $500,000. That means that – AS A PERCENTAGE OF THE LOAN AMOUNT – doc prep fees range (in this illustration) from .35% to .07%. In the latter case, there doesn’t seem to be a problem. But, in the former we only have 2.65% left to go and we are just getting started with one of the minimal fees. Underwriting and related fees typically range from $900 to $1600. Again, for an average set of underwriting costs of $1250, that’s 1.25% for a loan amount of $100,000 but only .25% of the $500,000 loan amount. It should take an Einstein to see that fixed loan costs quickly amount to more than 3% of loan amounts of $100,000 or so.

There are many fixed costs in loans. A percentage limitation does not allow enough flexibility to cover such costs. Other fixed costs include flood certifications, tax certifications, tax service fees, appraisals (having risen over 150% in costs since the advent of HVCC and Dodd-Frank), appraisal reviews, title/escrow fees, title insurance (varying from state to state although 3% works the same mathematically across the entire universe not to mention across state boundaries), courier fees. These fees represent individuals or firms who actually perform work on a loan file. Increasingly they represent people or firms who perform work that is required by government regulation. For example, the HVCC (Home Value Code of Conduct) rule (now under Dodd-Frank) created the need for appraisal management companies which, oddly enough, cannot perform their tasks for free or out of the goodness of their hearts. Real people working real hours in need of paying their own mortgages and putting food on their own table have to perform these tasks. How are these fees to be paid when an arbitrarily fixed percentage is mandated by a bureaucracy sitting in Washington, D.C. and does not allow for such costs; and such a fixed percentage especially is harmful when, because of inflation and government regulations, these costs actually rise sometimes when home prices are flat or actually declining.

Texas has proved that this fixed percentage does not work to the benefit of borrowers. Texas already has this rule (since about 1998) for equity loans. Because costs cannot exceed 3% of the loan amount and because THOSE COSTS DO NOT MAGICALLY GO AWAY JUST BECAUSE LEGISLATORS IN AUSTIN DECLARED THEY WERE UNLAWFUL, they still have to be paid. How are they paid? Those who know anything about lending understand that the lender must charge a higher interest rate to recoup the fixed costs in a loan. The higher the rate - the higher the yield. And since lenders cannot lose money by making loans, they must find a way to pay for these fees.

This 3% rule will mean higher interest rates for borrowers with lower loan amounts who already pay higher rates because of rate adjustments for low loan amounts. How does that benefit the consumer?  They pay a higher rate because a legislator (or in this case, a CFPB staffer) decided that an arbitrarily-contrived percentage was just enough, above which consumers should not pay without being “harmed.”

Even higher rates will not alleviate the shortage that this rule will produce. But, the problem is not solved by simply charging a higher interest rate. Yields which certain rates produce are not unlimited. That is, there is a point at which a higher rate not only does not pay more dollars but actually pays less. In other words, there is a ceiling limit beyond which a rate will pay no more dollars. What then does a lender do? How then will this conundrum be resolved? For years now, lenders have published loan amounts below which they will not lend. The reason is quite clear for anyone who cares to know the economics of lending and borrowing. Those minimal loan amounts will necessarily be instituted; if not by the actual lending company, by the originator.

How The Inclusion of Loan Officer Compensation Affects The Actual Price and Cost of a Mortgage

To make matters worse, loan officer compensation must be included in the 3% limitation. Besides the purely insane, Marxist nature of such a proposal, let us examine the practical effect of such a measure. As I have already demonstrated, the fixed costs can hardly be contained within the 3% limit on $100,000 loans in many cases. So, where now will loan officer compensation fit in such a scheme? It will fit ONLY IN LARGER LOAN AMOUNTS. That is also to say that the law of diminishing returns means that loan originators cannot afford to do loans below certain thresholds. It is not because they do not want to or because they would be unwilling to make a little less on one loan than another. The fact is, they would have to work for free – at certain loan amount thresholds, the originator would make $0 or, worse, pay a lender for the privilege of doing a loan for a customer.

Such a rule will produce the same moral hazard that all price controls produce – it will give rise to a black market whereby loan originators will perform task for favored individuals in exchange for money or favors that are completely off the grid. The indignation that politicians, government officials or CFPB staffers may express does nothing to produce access to credit for consumers.

The wiser and saner route for equal access to credit, good and fair prices and a robust housing market is really straightforward – do not institute the wage and price control measures currently ordered in the 3% closing costs limitations and its corollary limitation on loan officer compensation.

 
*The CFPB is the Consumer Finance Protection Bureau created by Dodd-Frank [Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act] (2010) to regulate America’s finance industry. It has unquestioned authority, writes its own rules and can levy sizeable enough fines to put a medium sized mortgage company out of business.

**The CFPB bulletins and publications are poorly dated but the URL address above indicates that the publication is most likely from January of 2013. But the readiness guide dated 7/8/2013 (http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201307_cfpb_mortgage-implementation-readiness-guide.pdf) has listed the following web-based publication which lays out guidelines for caps on points and fees which are to include Loan Officer Compensation. As you can tell, it is dated in April of this year. http://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201304_cfpb_compliance-guide_atr-qm-rule.pdf

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

New CFPB Rules: #1 - The 43% Rule . . . er, um, Scratch That - It's the 57% Rule

Richard Cordray of the CFPB declares "All American borrowers are stupid and we have to save them."

 
 
Well, he didn't use those exact words . . .
 
The CFPB is the Consumer Finance Protection Bureau created by Dodd-Frank [Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act] (2010) to regulate America’s finance industry. It has unquestioned authority, writes its own rules and can levy sizeable enough fines to put a medium sized mortgage company out of business.

The CFPB’s new rules will dramatically change mortgages beginning January 2014. The lynchpin of Dodd-Frank’s answer to the mortgage crisis is called the “Ability to Repay.” By adhering to a set of prescribed guidelines, the CFPB has created a “qualified mortgage” or QM. This QM is supposed to help lenders escape government scorn and reprimand (which can be very expensive for the offending lenders). But, to the casual reader, the new QM seems to also avoid legal peril - borrowers that come back and charge them with indigence; that is, failing to verify that the borrower could repay the loan.

According the proposed rules (and keep in mind that the CFPB proposes rules to itself and decides whether or not to accept its own proposals), the CFPB has effectively created the model mortgage. Deviate from it and a lender’s borrower can sue them to “forgive” the entire loan. The only things that are unclear as of March 2013 are the exceptions. For example, one theoretical exception is if the loan qualifies to be sold to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. In other words, if the Fannie/Freddie automated underwriting engines approve a loan (and an underwriter verifies that the loan file meets the specified conditions of this automated approval), then the loan is presumed to be a Qualified Mortgage. What we do not know is to what extent Fannie’s and Freddie’s guidelines will conform to the new QM rules. Inasmuch as there is only a “temporary” time period in which Fannie/Freddie approved loans transcend this rule, it’s virtually guaranteed that the first feature which the mortgage giants are likely to adopt is the 43% rule; or, as I like to call it . . .

The “Moron-Borrower” 43% Rule

To be fair, allow me to quote from the CFPB bulletin.

Cap on how much income can go toward debt: Qualified Mortgages generally will be provided to people who have debt-to-income ratios less than or equal to 43 percent. This cap on debt ensures consumers are only getting what they can likely afford. Before the crisis, many consumers took on mortgages that raised their debt levels so high that it was nearly impossible for them to repay the loan considering all their financial obligations. For a temporary, transitional period, loans that do not have a 43 percent debt-to-income ratio but meet government affordability or other standards such as that they are eligible for purchase by the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae) or the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac) will be considered Qualified Mortgages.

Before you decide whether 43% is too cold, too hot or juuuuuust right, consider

-       The old fashioned total debt ratio was 36% (27% housing obligation ratio; 36% total debt including housing ratio)

-       In the past 10 or more years, Fannie’s and Freddie’s automated underwriting systems routinely approved debt ratios of up to 60% and I’ve seen even higher than that.

-       Currently, Fannie, Freddie and HUD (for FHA, which used Fannie/Freddie underwriting engine) are approving debt ratios as high as 55%.

-       Foreclosure rates have dropped dramatically in the past three years; from their high point in 2010, they are now lower than at any time since the crisis began in early 2007. While there are many factors that contribute to this, tightened underwriting standards are being given some of the credit. This is a somewhat dubious claim since it is rarely newly financed homes that go into foreclosure. A longer timeline is necessary to measure the effect of underwriting standards on foreclosure rates. But, we cannot deny that there is some cause and effect. Clearly, the underwriting giants have taken maximum debt ratios into account when setting the parameters of loan approvals. This means, then, that debt ratios of higher than 43% pose no hard-and-fast negative factor to Fannie/Freddie/FHA.

-       43% total debt ratio leaves fewer dollars left over as “disposable” income for a lower income earner than for a higher income earner. For the income earner making $2,000/month, $1,140 is “left over” after 43% goes to debt. For the person making $10,000 per month, $5,700 is “left over.” And this is after taking into account the Jaguar payments. One can only pay so much for a pound of chicken. Which bring me to . . .

 
More importantly, it’s really not the 43% rule; rather, it’s the 57% rule. Consider the following excerpt from the proposed rules. Under Types of Qualified Mortgages: Qualified Mortgages with rebuttable presumption, the borrower has recourse if “the creditor did not consider their living expenses after their mortgage and other debts.” [emphasis mine] This means that the lender no longer just considers the now-famous “debt to income ratio” but the remaining income both as a dollar amount and a percentage of total income.

If you thought borrowers were frustrated with increased demands for more and more documentation, wait until we tell them there is an upfront charge of $750 for an independent CPA’s audit of the last two years of their personal finances; that is, enough information to underwrite the remaining 57% of gross income.

To truly take this rule into account and in order to prevent lawsuits, lenders will need to know what households spend on cable TV, groceries, restaurants, church and charitable contributions (some people give 10% and more of their gross income to “charities”), school fees/tuitions/supplies, gymnastics or cheer activities (have you seen the thousands of families whose lives nearly center around their child’s cheerleading or gymnastics?), clothing, work or union dues/expenses, vacations, sports, gambling excesses . . . the list is inexhaustible. And higher income earners have a whole range of other “high-dollar” activities. In order to keep a child in the equestrian sport or advanced “go-kart” racing, parents could easily spend $10,000/month or more.

And underwriters can only measure the past as a way to predict the future. So, what and how your clients are spending right now may well affect their loan approvals next year.
 
It is my view that the greatest fault of this rule is the “moral hazard.” It removes the responsibility for financial decision-making from the borrower and places it, nearly, solely upon the lender. This is not to say that the lender should not set its own standards. It is to say that folks with good credit are often qualified to borrow more money than they have good sense to borrow. And, one of the major reasons they are a (credit, income and asset) qualified borrower is because they have exercised that good sense. It is likely that this sort of consumer will continue to exercise good sense. But, economic moral hazards are about incentives. And the CFPB’s rule introduces the wrong sort of incentive – that of placing nearly all of the responsibility for spending too much or too little on goods and services with the creditor, and virtually none of it on the borrower.

That’s why I call it the “Moron-Borrower” rule. The all-superintending state assumes that all borrowers are morons and completely indigent, ill-motivated ones at that. Moreover, the rules assumes that it is the state's role to save American borrowers from themselves.

Divorcing/divorced borrowers will be especially affected. To date, those little extra elements in a decree that order spouses to pay certain fees, tuitions, health insurance premiums and innumerable other expenses have not been counted in a borrower’s debt ratio calculation. Only child support and alimony or spousal support payments (and sometimes loan repayment to ex-spouses) have been counted in debt ratios (either as income or as debt). I expect that lenders will be required to either count those heretofore excluded obligations in the debt ratio (maximum 43%) or will have to consider them in the remaining 57% calculation.

So, remember that it is really not the 43% rule. It’s the 57% rule.

A bit of a rabbit trail here but still relevant. Income (one half of the debt-to-income ratio) is likely to be scrutinized more severely – especially support income. Up until this past October, both conventional and FHA loans typically required a “pay history” of only 3 months in order for child or spousal support to be considered “qualifying” income. (That, and the other requirement that such income continue for 3 years after loan closing were the 2 factors that produced “qualifying” income). Conventional loans now require a pay history of 6 months and, in theory, may require up to 12 - 24 months of such history. FHA guidelines still allow for a 3-month pay history but I expect that to change as underwriting guidelines are evolving into a monolithic, government-sanctioned tablet from Mt. Sinai.

Well, let me ask you. When the feds (CFPB) really look at the fact that the demographic that is most likely to default on their mortgage debt is the newly-divorced mother, how do you think they will rule on the matter?

It is more important now than ever that those who are even considering divorce immediately begin my pre-divorce strategy that will allow both parties to qualify for their next mortgage; whether it is for refinancing or purchasing. Else, they will be waiting for a minimum of 3 months longer for their financing – not good for many clients who have to purchase immediately after final divorce using support income to qualify.

Please give me your comments and follow-up questions. I enjoy hearing from you and will take the time to respond thoughtfully and responsibly. noel@themortgageinstitute.com or 817-454-4555.

Noel Cookman

Thursday, March 14, 2013

NEW MORTGAGE RULES FROM THE CFPB

NEW RULES FROM DODD-FRANK'S CONSUMER FINANCE PROTECTION BUREAU ABOUT TO DEVASTATE AMERICA AND USHER IN A NEW DARK AGE


Okay, that’s a bit dramatic. But, it’s not totally untrue. (How’s that for word-smithing!)
 
The CFPB is the Consumer Finance Protection Bureau created by Dodd-Frank [Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act] (2010).
 
The CFPB’s new rules will dramatically change mortgages beginning January 2014. The lynchpin of Dodd-Frank’s answer to the mortgage crisis is called the “Ability to Repay.” By adhering to a set of prescribed guidelines, the CFPB has created a “qualified mortgage” or QM. This QM is supposed to help lenders escape government scorn and reprimand (which can be very expensive for the offending lenders). But, to the casual reader, the new QM seems to also avoid legal peril - borrowers that come back and charge them with indigence; that is, failing to verify that the borrower could repay the loan.

The CFPB is actually creating a new and unprecedented legal recourse for borrowers to pursue action against the lenders who advanced funds for their home purchase. To be clear, a borrower will be able to sue their lender and demand forgiveness for the loan based upon the claim that the (plaintiff) borrower could not repay the loan. In other words, the borrower doesn’t have any obligation to keep their commitment – it is the lender which must suffer loss should the borrower incur expenses which he may consider more expedient than his house payment. “Perish the thought,” you say? Responsible citizens have always limited their purchases and debts to what fit in after they made their house payment. Too bad for the lender whose borrower decides to upgrade their XBOX, mobile phone account, cable access, vehicles and vacations . . . and cannot seem to make the house payment. The lender should have known that their borrower could not “afford” the house.

A “safe harbor” is allegedly created by the lender who adheres to the standards of QMs. But, the actual safety of this “safe harbor” is really unclear as only in the rarest of circumstances does the lender not retain what is called “rebuttable presumption.”

“Rebuttable presumption” seems to mean, in the context of the CFPB’s rule, that the lender gets a presumption that they have satisfied the rule (verifying the borrower’s “ability to repay”); but, hold on here - the borrower never gives up their right to rebut that presumption. In other words, if a borrower does not make his house payment for any reason, he can now blame the lender for lending him money he could not repay.

Yes, it is counterintuitive. Yes, it is incredulous. Yes, it is insane. Yes, it is the product of regulation-happy politicians and bureaucrats whose IQ is somewhere south of a door-knob.
 
In case you think I’m the door-knob here, please read directly from the CFPB bulletin.
 
Types of Qualified Mortgages:

 Qualified Mortgages with rebuttable presumption: These are higher-priced loans typically for consumers with insufficient or weak credit history. If the loan goes south, the consumer can rebut the presumption that the creditor properly took into account their ability to repay the loan. They would have to prove the creditor did not consider their living expenses after their mortgage and other debts. This does not affect the rights of a consumer to challenge a lender for violating any other federal consumer protection laws.

 Qualified Mortgages with safe harbor: These are lower-priced loans that are typically made to borrowers who pose fewer risks. If the loan goes south, the lender will be considered to have legally satisfied the ability-to-repay requirements. But consumers can still legally challenge their lender under this rule if they believe that the loan does not meet the definition of a Qualified Mortgage. This does not affect the rights of a consumer to challenge a lender for violating any other federal consumer protection laws.

There really is no “safe harbor.” At the end of the day, there really is no sure way that a lender can satisfy the presumption that they have created a “qualified mortgage.”

Speaking of the new pope, enough of my pontificating, for now anyway. Let’s talk about the rules. And here they are (see if you can guess where I inserted my own moniker for each rule). Otherwise, I have copied and pasted these rules directly from the CFPB bulletin.


Features of Qualified Mortgages:

The “We-Didn’t-Think-This-One-Through-Just-Ask-Texas-Mortgage-Originators” 3% Rule
No excess upfront points and fees: A Qualified Mortgage limits points and fees including those used to compensate loan originators, such as loan officers and brokers. When lenders tack on excessive points and fees to the origination costs, consumers end up paying a lot more than planned.

 
The “Let’s-Kill-The-Fly-On-Grandpa’s-Head-With-a-Sledge-Hammer” Rule
No toxic loan features: Qualified Mortgages can’t have the loan features that were associated with risky mortgages in the lead up to the crisis. Certain loans cannot be Qualified Mortgages:

O No interest-only loans, which are when a consumer only pays the interest for a specified amount of time so the principal does not decrease with payments;
O No loans where the principal amount increases, such as a negative-amortization loan; and
O No loans where the term is longer than 30 years.


The “Moron-Borrower” 43% Rule
Cap on how much income can go toward debt: Qualified Mortgages generally will be provided to people who have debt-to-income ratios less than or equal to 43 percent. This cap on debt ensures consumers are only getting what they can likely afford. Before the crisis, many consumers took on mortgages that raised their debt levels so high that it was nearly impossible for them to repay the loan considering all their financial obligations. For a temporary, transitional period, loans that do not have a 43 percent debt-to-income ratio but meet government affordability or other standards such as that they are eligible for purchase by the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae) or the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac) will be considered Qualified Mortgages.

 
The “We-Assume-That-Borrowers-Are-Stupid-If-Not-Totally-Irresponsible” Rule
No loans with a balloon payment except those made by smaller creditors in rural or underserved areas: The law generally prohibits loans with balloon payments from being Qualified Mortgages. Balloon-payment loans require a larger-than-usual payment at the end of the loan term. A small creditor operating in rural or underserved areas is…
 
In the next few articles I will examine each rule and its major impact upon borrowers and especially upon divorcing borrowers. I will also deal with the significant and major flaw in Dodd-Frank, why it should be repealed and – SURPRISE - how the newly created CFPB could actually become a profoundly helpful agency of government regulations.

 

 

Wednesday, November 28, 2012


New Mortgage Guidelines Squeeze Divorcing Borrowers

Perhaps the headline title doesn’t sound urgent enough. So, how about this?

 Fewer Divorced Borrowers Qualify for Home Loans
 or
Good Luck Getting A Mortgage If You’re Divorced


Highlights – ALERT – URGENT ALERT!

 
-       No more 3 months of “pay history” for child or spousal support to qualify for a mortgage

-       6 months minimum and sometimes up to 24 months now required

 
First, a definition of terms. When getting a mortgage, one must think in terms of qualifying income, not merely income.

To illustrate by hyperbole (and a touch of sarcasm), income one receives from robbing convenience stores does not count as qualifying income unless it’s reported for the past 2 years on the thief’s tax returns. “Income from Theft” reports on line 1b under Part I of Schedule C - “Gross receipts or sales not entered on line 1a (see instructions).” Remember to deduct the “split” with your get-away driver on line 11 under Part II (you should issue him/her a 1099 at the end of the year); and fees to your lawyer can be deducted on line 17 under Part II.

The point is, your qualifying income is your “Net Profit/Loss” as reported on line 31 of Schedule C and averaged over the past two years. So you see, you may have had income of $100,000 from your crime spree last year (2011); but the $50,000 you gave to your driver and the $50,000 legal fees to your attorney make your qualifying income a big fat $0. But, you say, I didn’t get caught in 2010 (the previous year) and had no legal fees and I drove my own car so of the $100,000 I “earned” from robbing convenience stores I had no expenses deducted, shouldn’t my average income for two years be . . . let’s do some math here . . . $100,00 + $0 = $100,000 divided by 2 years = $50,000?

Not really. Underwriters see a pattern (forgetting for a moment your criminality) – it’s called “declining income” and, again, you draw a big fat zero.

Think QUALIFYING income. It’s a big deal!

And these are but a few of the many guidelines for qualifying income.

Now, what of the divorcing or divorced borrower; specifically for the borrower who is trying to get approved for a mortgage and using child support or some type of spousal support to qualify. What are the rules? What makes that income qualifying income?

Until October 20th of this year, the basic requirements were simple and straightforward. We called it the 3/36 guideline.

“3” - the borrower must have received the support for 3 months (it’s called a “pay history”) and

“36” - the underwriter has to assure its continuance for at least 36 months (easy enough to verify in a divorce decree since it specifies exactly how long support will continue). By the way, 35 months will not do – not a month less than 36 months after closing (not merely after final divorce).


Interestingly, we routinely helped divorcing borrowers develop a 3-month pay history relatively quickly. For instance, here we are at the end of November. I get a call and the applicant-client needs to qualify for a mortgage that must close at the end of December. How can we develop a 3-month history in 30 days? Very simply, the client is to receive the first support payment before the end of November for November’s support, then again on December 10th (or thereabouts) for December’s support and for the third time on December 15th for an early January support – *Merry Christmas! Really in about 18 days, we have created a legitimate 3-month history of support payments. Other guidelines apply. For example, it’s important which account pays the support and which account deposits it. (See me for those guidelines).

This is now a thing of the past. No longer does a 3-month pay history work. Lenders now require a minimum of 6 months of support payments received and can require as much as 24 months. Following the most aggressive pay history strategy (preceding paragraph), it will now take a minimum of about 4 months to develop this 6-month pay history. Just follow the calendar in the above example and you will see that at the end of March, the borrower might receive an early April payment to complete the 6 month history.

 
1st payment               November 28
2nd payment              December 1
3rd payment               January 1
4th payment               February 1
5th payment               March 1
6th payment               March 15th for April’s payment

*This does not always work but we have closed many transactions qualifying on this pattern of support income. In other words, it can work.


Winning Strategies for Family Law Attorneys and Divorcing Clients

In light of these momentous guideline changes, I am recommending the following strategies for divorcing mortgage applicants:

1.    Speak with me as early as possible. No more of this “here’s Noel’s card, he can help so you should call him” stuff. Clients need to hear something more like “Let’s get Noel on the phone right now” or “Go into my conference room after our appointment and dial up Noel immediately – you have to speak with him NOW.” Of course this is a shameless attempt to increase my business. But, it’s really a lot more than that. If your clients do not get started immediately, they may well lose the ability to obtain any mortgage financing or their spouses may be unable to qualify for financing thereby leaving them at risk.

2.    Unless you see reasons why not, both parties should immediately open their own checking accounts. At the very least, the recipient should open his/her own sole/separate bank account. This is critical for verifying that the applicant has indeed received the funds for himself or herself.

3.    The potential borrower and recipient of support payments should begin receiving support payments, albeit informally, immediately. (Document according to my customized and specific instructions).

4.    Potential borrower and recipient of support payments should begin paying the mortgage from his/her own account. If wife is going to be awarded the house and must refinance its mortgage and husband has been paying the mortgage, the two parties should arrange between the two of them for husband to pay wife support payments and wife should then pay the mortgage.

a.    This flow of funds (previous two paragraphs) accomplishes at least two very important qualifying features in a mortgage loan.

                                          i.    First, it establishes support payments paid and received.

                                        ii.    Secondly, the potential borrower begins to develop proof that she is making payments and thus, demonstrating that she has “the ability to afford the house payments.” I didn’t mention it but one of the new guidelines allows reduced documentation of support (from as much as 24 months down to only 6 months) only if the borrower demonstrates their ability to make the payments.

5.    The amount of support should equal or exceed the minimum expectations of support. Child support is fairly straightforward in terms of minimal amounts, as I understand it. Spousal support, negotiable as it may be, is another matter. In all cases, the borrower qualifies – there’s that word again – on the lower of the decree’s ordered amount or the actual pay history amount. The decree may order $2,500/month but if payments have only been $2,000/month then only the $2,000 can be used to calculate debt/income ratios, not the $2,500. Conversely, if payments have been $2,500 and only $2,000 is ordered, then the borrower qualifies on the $2,000. But, ‘tis better to develop a pay history that is inflated above the final amount awarded than to develop a pay history that is less than the final amount awarded.

 
DO NOT TRY THIS AT HOME

LET ME DEVELOP THE APPROVAL AND OUTLINE A PRECISE STRATEGY FOR A DIVORCING BORROWER TO QUALIFY FOR THEIR OWN MORTGAGE

 
The next boom to fall . . . support income measured as a too small of a percentage against total income may no longer be qualifying. Stay tuned.
 
Noel Cookman can be reached at 817-454-4555 or by email at Noel@TheMortgageInstitute.com.

Thursday, October 11, 2012

Qualified Assumptions - Is There Such A Thing?


Here is an email I received from a family law attorney last week. She succinctly stated the particulars of a case and then generalized the questions - perfect for a format like this. It deals with what some people are calling Qualified Assumptions (QA's).

Hi Noel,

I hope you are doing well.

I had an old client contact me with an interesting request and I’m hoping you can educate me (if you don’t mind, of course). In the divorce last year, husband was awarded the house & we execute the usual Special Warranty Deed and Deed of Trust to Secure Assumption for him to pay the mortgage. He did not refinance and wasn’t required to under the Decree.

The wife contacted him because she wants to buy a house. They ran her credit report and found her name on the mortgage of the marital residence, so they told her she would not qualify for a loan on the residence she wants to purchase. The husband contacted his mortgage lender, and they are allowing him to do a “Qualified Assumption” to remove wife’s name on the note without a refinance. The way he explained it to me, he basically has to qualify for the mortgage by himself, pay a fee of about $1,000, and the lender will remove her name from the mortgage so that it will clear the wife’s credit report.

In the past I knew that a mortgage company could sign a Release of Lien on a mortgage for a co-borrower, but in our experience, most mortgage companies won’t sign one, and the Courts will not order a Release of Lien because they cannot obligate a third party to waive their rights. This is the first we have heard of a Qualified Assumption and this type of relief being available in a divorce matter. Historically, we have counseled our clients that the only way to remove a person’s name from the mortgage is via a refinance.

Is there any information you can give to us about Qualified Assumptions? Is this new relief available to borrowers under the changed lending laws? Are QA’s common? Is this an option with all mortgage companies? Is this something that we can begin to offer to our clients as an alternative to refinance? Can we draft closing documents and/or Order language with regard to Qualified Assumptions? I’d appreciate any guidance you can provide us.

Thank you so much.

Attorney at Law
Houston, Texas



My response...

Dear Attorney Friend,

This is an excellent and timely question.

I have a complete response to the question about “Qualified Assumptions.” But the most pressing issue is the ex-spouse who now is told she cannot purchase a house because of this liability. She is being denied, not because of this liability but, because she is not working with me. Everything else being equal, she can qualify to purchase on her own with a couple of simple things: 1) the decree, 2) the ex-husband’s cooperation to provide documentation of pay history. But, this is a transaction that must be wisely packaged and submitted – something we have been doing with regularity and success for over a decade now. The quickest resolution is for this client to call me at 817-454-4555 or email me at noel@themortgageinstitute.com.


Now, to your questions about "qualified assumptions":

Q: Is there any information you can give to us about Qualified Assumptions?

A: Not much because of reasons that will be obvious below. But, I do hope to clarify some things for you and all concerned.


Q: Is this new relief available to borrowers under the changed lending laws?

A: No. “Qualified Assumption” is the name that this bank (in question) has given to some process or program that they might have. But, we do not know as it is highly unlikely that even this bank publishes information on this program. If they did, we might grant the idea more credibility. As it is, my experience is that banks (especially the big ones that employ call-center reps to handle mortgage applications) will use any term the caller uses. If the caller says “can you modify my mortgage” the employee will say “sure, let me get some information.” If the caller says “can I get my ex-wife off the mortgage by assuming it as my own debt” the employee will say “sure, let me get some information.” In fact, the bank is taking an application to refinance the mortgage. They want to keep the customer but they effectively have to make sure that the remaining borrower is “qualified.”


Q: Are QA’s common?

A: No. But again, Qualified Assumptions are not government-prescribed programs – although the name is similar to phrases bandied about.

For example, Qualified Residential Mortgage (QRM) is a regulation term currently promised (i.e., threatened) under Dodd-Frank that refers to underwriting/qualifying standards. But, as Romney pointed out in the debate (October 3), the government still hasn’t defined a QRM although the threat of not adhering to these yet-to-be written standards looms over our collective head. An older type of mortgage(s) is the “assumable” often designated as either a “Non-Qualifying Assumable” or a “Qualifying Assumable.” These were mostly FHA (government insured) mortgages and VA loans but have gone the way of rotary dial phones. Although the contrary might seem to be obvious, the government is effectively creating “non-qualifying” programs but that’s another issue and doesn’t apply here.

Neither are QA’s industry-prescribed programs. There is no product that we know of that is characterized as a Qualifying Assumption. However, keep in mind that each bank can create programs and lend according to their own standards so long as they do it within the law and do not care whether that loan is salable to Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac or insurable by HUD or guaranteed by the VA. With respect to this fact, I cannot say that a QA does not exist, only that if they do, they are out of my sight line and probably rare.


Q: Is this an option with all mortgage companies?

No. It’s not an option with hardly any of them, maybe none of them. We have heard about a few of them but have actually seen none of them.


Q: Is this something that we can begin to offer to our clients as an alternative to refinance?

A: I hope the answer is obvious. But, offering such an alternative, even in theory, I believe would be disastrous. I see the effects of these misunderstandings all the time in my work. But consider this: Even in seemingly standard cases, only a qualified mortgage professional – really a Divorce-Mortgage Specialist in these cases – can qualify or disqualify a potential borrower. And even this professional must do diligence in order to provide such a statement of approval or denial. No amount of other parties or professionals or judges or attorneys, whether in court or in mediation or in collaboration or in settlement meetings, can make these sorts of determinations even in instances wherein it appears a borrower might be well qualified. This is why I do what I do.

Q: Can we draft closing documents and/or Order language with regard to Qualified Assumptions?
A: I certainly would not tell an attorney what she can do in regards to drafting legal documents. And I am not even close to your level of intelligence and expertise. If the time ever came when banks were issuing statements of “Qualified Assumption” approvals, I recommend that you analyze them carefully and craft agreements based only upon the strongest of commitments from these banks. As well, please call me and let me analyze these statements.

What I do as a matter of practice is take an application from a divorcing client, qualify them based on standard and special conditions, report to you, the attorney, in an Assessment/Approval these special conditions, review drafts of the decree making suggestions and follow through during the process of divorce to assure that when the decree is entered, the client-borrower will always be able to close their loan, our having already underwritten and approved it.
To expect this from a bank who claims to be transacting a “Qualified Assumption” is probably unrealistic. But, I’m all for exploring uncharted territories.



All of the above notwithstanding, I do think that there are banks that, for a fee, offer a version of this “Qualified Assumption” whereby a borrower’s name is “removed” from the note by the remaining borrower qualifying with his/her own income and assets and other qualifying features. However, a few things bother me about this:
First of all, how does the former borrower know that the lender has truly released him/her from the mortgage liability? The lender cannot send them a “paid” status on the mortgage. Even if the lender sends them a letter that says they are no longer liable – and I seriously doubt this happens without the remaining borrower actually refinancing the existing mortgage . . . in which case, the “ex” borrower would receive the “paid” status letter – the allegedly former borrower needs to understand that the lender still has their Social Security number (and can report pay histories to credit bureaus against that name and SS number) and a promissory note with their signature on it that promises to repay the debt. Nothing but full repayment of that debt releases any person who has signed that note.


Secondly, unless the note is actually being refinanced, what new deed is filed? How does the deed change? How can it be replaced? A lender can more easily change the note (to the benefit of the borrower) than it can meddle with the deed. Special Warranty Deeds do not change names on the original Deed of Trust. And of course, they never alleviate a party of a credit obligation.


Thirdly, the lien cannot be truly released (without full payment); else, the lender has no security on their collateral property. If the lien is not released, from the perspective of the borrower who is seeking the removal of this liability, it is always a contingent and real liability.


Fourthly, and this goes to motivation, why would a lender do this? They will do it for one reason only – preserving their own interests. This is a good motivation as it drives our free market and capitalism itself. But, we must wonder what a lender is up to if they actually release one half of the source of payment from the obligation. Banks make a little bit of money by upfront fees, etc. Their real money is made by collecting interest payments over a longer period of time. To endanger this income flow is contrary to a sound business model. The prospects of losing the loan may outweigh the lender’s concern about losing one of its borrower’s promises of repayment. However, if the loan is likely to be lost, as in lost to another refinancing lender, then there is usually more incentive for the borrower to refinance (possibly to a lower interest rate) than to simply “assume” sole liability for a fee.

  Speaking of assumptions, unless and until either the mortgage industry or the government (God forbid) produces a product called a "Qualified Assumption," it is unwise to assume that such a program exists or that some bank can be convinced to remove an obligated borrower with a few strokes of a pen. And if that happens, guidelines will be published so that upon them we can "hang our hat."

A truly "qualified" product is a refinancing of the mortgage note.